WHERE IS THE LINE?

I've spent all day working on a presentation for my HOA Board. It's important to me that my voice is heard.

SLIDE 1 — WHERE IS THE LINE?
This started with two plastic skeletons, but the larger question is: where is the line?
I walked around the neighborhood because I wanted to understand what we actually look like — not hypothetically, but in real life.

And we’re eclectic. There are lions, dogs, geese, angels, skeletons, yard flags, flagpoles, lights, planters, wreaths, wind chimes, and all kinds of things people use to make their homes feel like theirs.

These aren’t complaints. I’m making the opposite point.

We don’t all have to like the same things. I don’t like every decoration I see, and I don’t expect everyone to like mine.

But if we’re going to have rules — and therefore violations of those rules — homeowners need an objective standard they can understand before enforcement begins.
Seasonal? Decorative? Permanent? Violation?

Where is the line?

SLIDE 2 — WHY I’M HERE
I’m not here to fight over two plastic skeletons, and I’m not asking for a special exception. I’m asking for clarity, consistency, and fairness. When I was contacted, I tried to find the rule I had violated and couldn’t find a clear written seasonal-decoration standard. My goal is a constructive solution for all homeowners — conversation, not confrontation.

SLIDE 3 — WHAT HAPPENED
I moved here in 2019 and have decorated ever since. We’ve had year-round exterior lights and put up Christmas decorations beginning November 1. Two five-foot skeletons arrived in October 2025. We enjoyed them so much that we began dressing them for different seasons, and neighbors complimented them. In September, I was told to remove them or seek ARB approval. I made a good-faith change by removing the lamp-post display and moving the second skeleton to the stoop. Now the Board is drafting a decorations policy, which I think is an opportunity to make the expectations clearer for everyone.

And regardless of what policy is ultimately adopted, I've already decided that the skeletons will come inside on November 1. I think that's a reasonable compromise, and it's one I would have agreed to from the beginning if someone had simply asked.

I'd like to start next year's Halloween display on September 1, but if the rule is October 1, I will respect and follow it.

SLIDE 4 — ENCOURAGEMENT vs. ENFORCEMENT
The Association has encouraged residents to decorate. But I have not found a definition explaining when a removable decoration becomes a “permanent improvement,” or whether seasonal and non-seasonal décor are treated differently.

And that raises a very basic consistency problem.

If a plastic skeleton that can simply be picked up and carried inside is a permanent improvement, why isn’t a wind chime? Why isn’t a yard flag? A porch goose? Lion statues?

I'm not suggesting that any of those things should require approval or be removed. I'm asking why one removable decorative object falls into this category while another doesn't.
And the answer can't depend on whether somebody complained about one of them. A complaint can identify something the Association should look at. It cannot, by itself, define what the rule is.

Unwritten expectations are impossible to apply consistently.
​
So again: where is the line?

SLIDE 5 — THE MISSING STEP 
One email could have changed the entire trajectory of this situation. If I had been contacted after the first concern or told, “We don’t have a clear seasonal-decoration policy, but since Halloween is approaching, would you be willing to remove the skeletons by November 1 while the Board develops one?” I would have agreed to that. In fact, that is essentially the compromise I eventually reached on my own.

I know that approach can work because I’ve been the complaining neighbor.

I don’t like wind chimes. Years ago, one particular wind chime across the street bothered me. I spoke with my neighbor, and she moved it.

My dislike of wind chimes did not ban them for the entire neighborhood. My complaint started a conversation. It didn’t create a rule.

But when neighbors complained about my skeletons, I was told to remove them, with no indication that I could put them back out for Halloween or when they would be permitted again.

That’s the distinction I’m struggling with.

The problem was the process, timing, framing, and lack of a defined rule. A complaint could have led first to a conversation and then, if the Board believed a broader standard was necessary, to a policy that applied to everyone. Instead, enforcement came before the policy existed.

​SLIDE 6 — THE HUMAN SIDE
I also want to acknowledge the human side. When you have an anxiety disorder, an anonymous complaint can feel much bigger than one person's objection. It can very quickly start to feel like everybody is looking at you.

That doesn't mean complaints shouldn't be addressed. It means how they are communicated matters.
​
And I recognize that managing a community is work. I'm not interested only in criticizing the process; I'm volunteering to help improve it.

SLIDE 7 — QUESTIONS FOR THE BOARD
I think a policy needs to answer four basic things.

1. What is the standard? What distinguishes seasonal décor, non-seasonal décor, and a permanent improvement? Does simply remaining outside for a long time transform an otherwise removable object into a permanent improvement?

2. What factors matter — duration, placement, size, quantity, visibility?

3. What actually requires ARB approval?

4. And what is the process? Will homeowners have input before adoption, and how will the final standard be communicated and applied consistently?

SLIDE 8 — WHAT I’M ASKING FOR
My request is simple: a clear written policy, homeowner input before adoption, consistent application, and the opportunity to help.

I'm not asking the Board to adopt my preferred policy tonight. I'm asking that homeowners know what is being proposed before it becomes enforceable, that comparable objects be treated under the same standard, and that everyone know the rule before they can be accused of violating it.

And I'm genuinely volunteering to help with that process.

SLIDE 9 — INVITE INPUT
This resolution will affect much more than skeletons. It could affect flags, wreaths, lights, yard figures, inflatables, porch decorations, cultural displays, memorials, and all kinds of things residents currently put outside their homes.

That's why I think residents should see the actual proposal before it's finalized rather than learning what it means when something they own becomes an enforcement issue.

The whole neighborhood should have a chance to understand what is being proposed and give input.

SLIDE 10 — COMPLIMENTS COUNT, TOO
This experience also made me notice that complaints create a record, while compliments usually don't.

So a complaint is evidence that someone objects. It isn't necessarily evidence of community consensus.

A complaint can identify a problem, but a compliment can tell us what residents value. I'd like us to think about ways to hear both.

SLIDE 11 — CLOSING
And yes, I made a Real Housewives of Pantops logo because sometimes humor helps.

I really don’t want this to become a reality show. I’d rather turn a small dispute into something useful: clearer expectations, better communication, resident input, and a policy everyone can understand before they are told they’ve violated it.

I don't need the Board to agree with me about skeletons. I do want us to agree that homeowners should be able to know the rules before they're told they've broken them.

Different vibes. Same neighborhood. Let’s choose conversation over conflict.

---

OPEN LETTER TO MY NEIGHBORS

---

---

THE SHORT VERSION

Dear Neighbor,

I understand that you contacted the HOA about my decorations. I would genuinely like to understand what bothered you.

You do not need to identify yourself to me. If possible, I’d appreciate having the specific issue shared anonymously. I’m also open to having a private or mediated discussion.

The decorations bring joy to my family, but I also care about being a good neighbor. Knowing whether the issue is the skeletons themselves, their size, or their placement could help us find a reasonable compromise.

I hope situations like this can be resolved through conversation whenever possible.
​
Leah

---

THE LONG VERSION

Dear Neighbor,

I don’t know who you are, and I’m not asking to know.

But since your complaint about my decorations has now prompted a much larger conversation about decorating in our neighborhood, there are a few things I wish I could have said to you directly at the time of the complaint, but I'm saying it now openly to whomever may read this. 

First: I wish you had talked to me.

I genuinely mean that.

Finding out that even one neighbor disliked my decorations was disheartening. I wondered almost immediately: If you knew how much decorating my home means to me, would you still have complained? Maybe you would have. And that would be okay. But at least we would understand each other a little better.

I bought this townhouse in 2019. It is the first home I have ever owned. One of the things I have loved about it is having a little patch of outdoors that is mine to decorate.

The skeletons arrived for Halloween in October 2025. I liked them so much that I left them up and started changing them for the seasons: Valentine boas and hearts, St. Patrick’s Day hats, bunny ears, American flags. They were silly. They made me happy. And based on the unsolicited comments I have received from people walking through the neighborhood, they made some other people happy too.

That doesn’t mean everyone has to like them.

I don’t like everything my neighbors choose either.

I hate wind chimes.

One person’s soothing wind chime is another person’s relentless clanging. One person’s
creepy skeleton is another person’s year-round friend.

That seems like a pretty good metaphor for living in a neighborhood.

You keep yours. I’ll keep mine. And somewhere in between, we figure out how to live next to each other.

What has troubled me most about this situation isn’t that somebody dislikes my skeletons. You are absolutely entitled to dislike them.

It is that a private difference in taste became an official complaint—and because I could not find a written decoration rule that specifically prohibited what I had done, I suddenly had no idea what standard I had violated.

When there isn’t a clear rule, a complaint can effectively become one.

And complaints create a record. Compliments don’t.

For every person who complains about something in a neighborhood, there may be other people who smile when they pass it. The HOA never hears from them. That doesn’t make their opinions more important than yours. It just means neither of us should automatically get to decide for everyone else.

That is why I would rather have a conversation than a conflict.

Had you knocked on my door and said, “Hey, those skeletons bother me,” I can’t promise I would have taken them down immediately, but I would have listened. I would have wanted to know what bothered you. I might have moved something, removed something, changed something, or discovered a compromise neither of us had considered.

In fact, after the complaint, I did change the display. I removed the lights from the lamppost and moved the skeleton that had been standing there. When I looked at the two skeletons together on the stoop afterward, I realized something surprising:
I liked them better that way.

Maybe sometimes a complaint really is an opportunity to do better.

But I think we can do better than anonymous complaints, too.

We are all neighbors. We should be able to talk to each other about our concerns and our motivations. We should be able to acknowledge that what delights one person may annoy another—and that neither reaction automatically makes someone wrong.

So if you ever want to talk to me about the skeletons, please do.

You don’t have to like them.

I would just rather know my neighbor than know there was a complaint.

I've moved through the stages of grief and have accepted that my skeletons will most likely only see the sunshine in October. That's ok. They've served their purpose. ​
And for what it’s worth, I've ordered a second porch goose. I really hope it's an acceptable alternative. 😀 

Leah